Who stole the cookie from the cookie jar?

Well who can blame you, if they’re Keystone Cookies! Our cookies are made the old-fashioned way. From scratch, using only the best ingredients like real vanilla extract, real butter, fancy walnuts and farm fresh eggs! From all-American favorites like chocolate chip and sugar, to fancier varieties, the list seems endless.

  • Oatmeal
  • Oatmeal Raisin
  • Chocolate Chip
  • Walnut Chocolate Chip
  • Cranberry Chocolate Chip
  • Angel Puffs
  • Peanut Butter
  • Caramel Iced
  • Fondant Thumbprints: One free sample for each kid who visits our bakery and they come in all of the local school colors! (Note: these cookies are rolled in rolled walnuts so beware of nut allergies, please!)


Movies have been made about this delightful treat! Biscotti are a twice-baked cake originating in the Italian city of Prato. The cakes are large biscuits made dry and crunchy through cutting the loaf of dough while still hot and fresh from baking in the oven. Coffee and biscotti…no better way to spend an afternoon with friends.

  • Anise
  • Almond
  • Cherry Walnut
  • Cocoa Almond

Flakies (Kolache)

You’ve probably had this at a wedding reception, but if you haven’t tried ours, you’re in for a special treat! A sweet pastry consisting of a semisweet yeast dough Kolache are baked with fillings such as fruits, and nuts and topped with a crumbled mixture of sugar, flour and butter. Kolache originated as a wedding dessert in Central Europe and have become very popular around the world.

  • Apricot
  • Nut
  • Apricot Nut Combo
  • Mini Cream Rolls (Ladylocks): We can’t make enough of these!